Acceleration Economy
  • Home
  • Cloud Wars
  • Analyst Content
    • By Category
      • AI/Hyperautomation
      • Cloud/Cloud Wars
      • Cybersecurity
      • Data
    • By Interest
      • Leadership
      • Office of the CFO
      • Partners Ecosystem
      • Sustainability
    • By Industry
      • Financial Services
      • Healthcare
      • Manufacturing
      • Retail
    • By Type
      • Guidebooks
      • Digital Summits
      • Practitioner Roundtables
      • Practitioner Playlists
    • By Language
      • Español
  • Vendor Shortlists
    • All Vendors
    • AI/Hyperautomation
    • Cloud
    • Cybersecurity
    • Data
  • What we do
    • Advisory Services
    • Marketing Services
    • Event Services
  • Who we are
    • About Us
    • Practitioner Analysts
  • Subscribe
Twitter Instagram
  • CIO Summit
  • Summit NA
  • Dynamics Communities
Twitter LinkedIn
Acceleration Economy
  • Home
  • Cloud Wars
  • Analyst Content
        • By Category
          • AI/Hyperautomation
          • Cloud/Cloud Wars
          • CybersecurityThe practice of defending computers, servers, mobile devices, electronic systems, networks, and data from malicious attacks.
          • Data
        • By Interest
          • Leadership
          • Office of the CFO
          • Partners Ecosystem
          • Sustainability
        • By Industry
          • Financial Services
          • Healthcare
          • Manufacturing
          • Retail
        • By Type
          • Guidebooks
          • Digital Summits
          • Practitioner Roundtables
          • Practitioner Playlists
        • By Language
          • Español
  • Vendor Shortlists
    • All Vendors
    • AI/Hyperautomation
    • Cloud
    • Cybersecurity
    • Data
  • What we do
    • Advisory Services
    • Marketing Services
    • Event Services
  • Who we are
    • About Us
    • Practitioner Analysts
  • Subscribe
    • Login / Register
Acceleration Economy
    • Login / Register
Home » How Procurement Can Tap Automation to Enhance the CFO Relationship
AI/Hyperautomation

How Procurement Can Tap Automation to Enhance the CFO Relationship

Joanna MartinezBy Joanna MartinezMarch 18, 2023Updated:March 18, 20236 Mins Read
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Email
CFO CPO Procurement Automation
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Email
AE Leadership

It’s common for procurement executives to tout the savings they’ve achieved and the impact they’ve had on the organization. It’s equally common for the chief financial officer (CFO) and their counterparts to push back with, “What savings? How come we don’t see them? Why are our costs increasing year on year if you’re doing such a good job reducing them?”

Both sides have a point. Chief procurement officers (CPO) try to quantify their value to the organization by identifying the cost of a widget at a point in time and comparing it to a newly negotiated price. But an “old price vs. new price” comparison isn’t enough — because specifications and volume fluctuate, and the good or service being negotiated may be new, so there may not be any “old” spend against which to compare. Adding to the complexity: There may be thousands of items being purchased.

See the AI/Hyperautomation Top 10 Shortlist

CFOs get frustrated when an answer isn’t readily available and the response is, “I’ll get back to you.” When the CPO marshals his/her team to detail and justify their assumptions, they become focused on tactical analysis and take time away from projects that support the business strategy. I’ve been there; once the CFO starts questioning results, it feels like there is a black cloud hanging over procurement. Taking the steps outlined in this analysis — particularly automation — will create a framework to enhance communication and the overall relationship with your CFO.

Where CPOs and CFOs Misunderstand Each Other

Let’s start by reviewing some key reasons the CFO may be skeptical of procurement’s contribution.

Difference in Focus

CFOs operate at the highest levels of the company and have broad financial goals, typically targeted at growing revenue and improving profitability. CPOs who have a laser focus on cost reductions are likely to be seen as tactical contributors, not strategic partners. When a procurement team is loaded with experts in specific categories, there is a tendency for professionals to dive deeply into the categories they know well and not always challenge spend and processes across the entire supply chain.

Insufficient Depth

CPOs tend to report on the direct cost savings achieved through procurement, while the CFO may be looking at the total cost of ownership, including indirect costs such as supplier performance, quality, and risk. That’s a lost opportunity for procurement because if the analysis is incomplete, it means that the team is understating its value. One of the reasons CPOs may stay focused on savings is because it can be a very manual process to gather additional data that the CFO requires. This is where automation can help, making it easier to get into more in-depth cost analysis.

Difference in Approach

CFOs rely on hard data and financial analysis to make decisions. This means they have a natural aversion to reported results that do not have a clear methodology and supporting data. If CPOs are unable to provide clear and detailed information on how they have achieved their savings, then CFOs will not fully believe their claims.

No Process to Retain Achieved Savings

According to Insight Sourcing Group, up to 40% of savings evaporate once a sourcing event is done. One contributor is rogue spend, which occurs when there are gaps in the purchase process and policies that allow purchasers across the firm to buy from whomever they choose, without penalty. That means that no matter the deal, volume with the preferred supplier will always fall short.

Insights into the Why & How of AI & Hyperautomation's Impact_featured
Guidebook: Insights into the Why & How of AI & Hyperautomation’s Impact

How to Improve CFO-CPO Communication

At a high level, there are three steps to fixing these differences in perspective and communication, which will go a long way toward helping the CPO optimize its relationship with the CFO.

Give Them Data on Their Terms

The first step is to understand how the CFO wants to see results reported. There are so many possible ways of calculating savings that it doesn’t matter what the CFO wants or what the prior CFO chose — the value is in the trend over time. Do the CFO and head of supply chain want to see it in two different ways? Show it both ways. One executive team with which I worked couldn’t agree on four different calculations. In the end, they didn’t have to. We gave them ROI based on fully loaded costs, strategic headcount only, including transition costs, and not including transition costs. It doesn’t matter what the calculation actually is; what matters is the consistency of the calculation and the trend over time.

Make and Enforce Rogue Spending Rules

It’s essential to create policies that clearly spell out the rules and expectations on rogue spend. It doesn’t matter how good the deal is; if there are no consequences for rogue spend, then employees will continue to buy from whomever they choose. If this happens, the volumes on which a contract is based can never be achieved.

Automate, Automate, Automate

To provide this broader and deeper swathe of reports, it helps to automate as much of the process as you can for each item where a new price has been negotiated. The more this is automated, the less a CPO will need to divert the team from more strategic projects. Here are a few specific ways to tap automation:

  • Pull volume data from accounts payable (AP) and measure it against the forecast
  • Use your contract management tool to provide the negotiated prices, then audit invoices from the supplier in question to determine if they’re in compliance
  • Run AP summaries in each category to identify suppliers that shouldn’t be there (a result of bad coding or rogue spend)

With this approach, you won’t need to divert the procurement team from strategic activities to work on ways to organize or make sense of all the data gathered by automation tools. The ability to have it organized and summarized into reports likely already resides within your ERP, AP, or contract management system. Just ask for some help from the IT team, if needed. Automating the data collection enables procurement brainpower to be focused on analyzing the results in necessary and nuanced ways, anticipating CFO questions in the process. Another bonus: Manual errors will be reduced.

It’s a good idea to invite a finance department designee appointed by the CFO to audit the process. This helps catch and address outliers before the CFO asks a question you can’t answer. Just as important, the designee can function as an influencer. If someone from the finance department endorses the process, it goes a long way to making the CFO feel comfortable. Come to think of it, the CPO, and their department, will be a lot more comfortable, too.


Want more tech insights for the top execs? Subscribe to the Leadership channel:

AE Leadership

automation CXO data data analytics data management ERP featured finance hyperautomation leadership
Share. Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Email
Analystuser

Joanna Martinez

Founder
Supply Chain Advisors

Areas of Expertise
  • Chief Procurement Officer
  • Supply Chain
  • Website
  • LinkedIn

Joanna Martinez is an Acceleration Economy Analyst focusing on Procurement and Supply Chain. As the founder of Supply Chain Advisors, LLC, she helps individuals and businesses achieve their transformational goals by better leveraging technology, engaging stakeholders, and improving processes. Joanna has led transformation initiatives for firms in different sectors, from consumer products and pharma to financial and professional services. She is an advisor for two technology startups, a professional services firm, and the School of Engineering at Rutgers University. For the last four years, she has been designated a Top Global Influencer and Thought Leader in multiple categories by Thinkers360 Her book, A Guide to Positive Disruption, draws on her experiences making positive changes at the organizations for which she has worked and provides a framework to follow for those who want to be successful in a business undergoing disruption.

  Contact Joanna Martinez ...

Related Posts

Why Cybersecurity Leaders Need to Know the CISA Zero Trust Maturity Model

March 30, 2023

Let’s Talk Transformation | Strategy

March 30, 2023

How Informatica Unlocks Digital Transformation With AI-Powered Data Management Platform

March 30, 2023

How ChaptGPT Plugins Create New AI Value, Including Real-Time Information

March 30, 2023
Add A Comment

Comments are closed.

Recent Posts
  • Why Cybersecurity Leaders Need to Know the CISA Zero Trust Maturity Model
  • Let’s Talk Transformation | Strategy
  • How Informatica Unlocks Digital Transformation With AI-Powered Data Management Platform
  • How ChaptGPT Plugins Create New AI Value, Including Real-Time Information
  • How to Prioritize IT Projects and Explain Their Value to the C-Suite, Board, and Business Units

  • 3X a week
  • Analyst Videos, Articles & Playlists
  • Exclusive Digital Business Content
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Most Popular Guidebooks

Securing Multi-Cloud Ecosystems

March 24, 2023

Securing Software-as-a-Service Applications

March 1, 2023

Retail Innovation With AI, Data, and Cybersecurity

March 1, 2023

Cloud Data Strategy, Analytics, and Governance

February 27, 2023

Advertisement
Acceleration Economy
Twitter LinkedIn
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Get In Touch
  • Advertising Opportunities
© 2023 Acceleration Economy.

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

  • Login
Forgot Password?

Connect with

Login with Google Login with Windowslive

Lost your password? Please enter your username or email address. You will receive a link to create a new password via email.